Comments (27)Add a Comment
I agree with Gwen, What is with Twigpaw's name???!!!! I think that Twigstrike would be a good name or maybe Twigpelt, but TwigBranch???!!! I also think that Sparkpelt should have been SparkHeart (R.I.P Firestar) And why do the Erins kill so many characters?? Honestly, I was so sad when BriarLight died. I like the idea of having Skyclan back though. Please like if you agree!!
Oof i spent only 3 years no reading this series and im 10 books behind
good books though
ive been studying (not reading) this series for 5 years now, and it really seems like the Erin's like to kill characters for no reason when they have a bad name, BYE TWIGBRANCH!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I agree with nadiakashif2000, yanpingpi, jsewell24, and minyi05. I really loved Warriors in the beginning, but A Vision of Shadows is by far the worst sub-series out of all six of them. The characters have gone downhill—I mean Violetshine and Alderheart are still okay characters but Twigpaw is just whiny, silly, and ungrateful. Plus, (I know lots of reviewers have already mentioned this) why does Bramblestar name her Twigbranch? What an annoying name! How about Twigpelt, or Twigsong, or Twigstrike or anything but Twigbranch!
The supposed plot "twists" I could see coming from a mile away. The writing was clunky at best and the romance was totally contrived. I am overall super disappointed in this book. Like my comment if you agree.
I supposed the reason why Warriors sometimes fails is that Erin Hunter is actually made up of six different authors, with different writing styles/techniques, different ideas, and different opinions. And because of this things can get messy, which is a shame because cat Clans is such a great premise for a series, and I have really enjoyed some of the Warriors books.
Oh, well. It is what it is. I just hope the next book and Bravelands are good.
Apparently, you need a movie maker to actually approach the author then they can make a movie.
But I digress.
I totally agree though about one thing in particular.
WHY? I constantly feel like I'm starting to hate the Warriors series. I really liked the first series, featuring Firestar. But I no longer like Warriors anymore. It's almost like Erin Hunter is trying to destroy my childhood. And Tigerstar, how wrong is that? Sorry, but like most people, I agree it sounds a whole lot like Firestar's old arch-nemesis. So YEAH.
Erin Hunter would be lucky if I don't send her any hate mail.
I know. SPOILER though everyone kind of knows it...
Twigpaw becomes TwigBranch. Like really?!!! Who has a name like that?!
Twig and branch are theoretically the same thing, the Erins said thy would start using fandom names but clearly it doesn't seem like they are >:( oh also, TIGERSTAR... get it the TIGERSTAR, the one who hates Firestar! So for Tigerheart to return home (if you read Tigerhearts Shadow you know), he gets to become leader and Dovewing… But Tigerheart as TIGERSTAR just sounds wrong, SPOILER: it is sad that Onestar is dead :(
And violetshines additude is OMG I don't know what to do , Twingbranch is complete dumb.
The warriors series is going downhill, and WHERE IS THE MOVIE???!!!!!!!
WARNING: Contents contain spoilers.
OMG! So good. (Spoiler) But Twigbranch?! Erin Hunter's running out of names…….. A twig and a branch is (technically) the same thing! (Spoiler) And weren't SkyClan and ShadowClan supposed to be allies? (Spoiler) ShadowClan is in trouble……….. There won't be a ShadowClan soon……. (Spoiler) What about Tigerstar the second?
Amazing book! Definitely worth your time. But.................couldnt they have given Twigbranch a better name...? Also...............Tigerheart as tiger star.......I wonder where thats going to lead too.........BUT overall it was a really good book!
It’s taking forever for me to get this book! I’ve been waiting months for this! I hope it is good,otherwise it was a waste of time! Also,can somebody tell a staff member to add more copies someone please ask them🤞🤞🤞
*2 days later*
Yes!!!! It’s in transit!!! I can bring it on my family vaycay to Toronto!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
This book wasn't bad as the other ones, but it lacked development and more, what the heck is a name called "Twigbranch" I'm disappointed in this book. Don't ruin the bravelands please.
Twigbranch was bland and in the book all they did was walk around the lake.
Briarlight, the only good character left died. Finleap lacked development and acted like a bland apparentice. Maybe this has to be the last warriors arc.
ALSO WHERE's THE MOVIE? IT WAS ANNOUNCED IN 2016!
good book, but I did notice Finpaws personality totally changed, and Twigbranch? what the heck that name sucks it was great for the events in the book except for when Twigbranch went to the moon pool, thats just messed up she was so stupid for that it didn't even really help anyone oh yeah and READ TIGERHEARTS SHADOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! one more thing, THERE WAS SUPPOSED TO BE A MOVIE????????????????? NOBODY TOLD ME ANYTHING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Dissapointed. The warriors series used to be good, but now it's boring and uneventful. I hate both Violetpaw and Twigpaw's attitude.
I haven't read it yet, but I know it's going to be great! I'm a longtime Warriors fan. :3
but uGhHh did they really have to call her TWIGBRANCH? That's so redundant and weird. Violetpaw got such a nice name. (Violetshine) I don't know, maybe Erin Hunter is running out of names. (she could have been twigripple, twig dream, twigpool, twigbreeze, twigclaw, AND MORE.)
Disappointed. Maybe Erin is writing too many books. I just hope the new Survivor book is better.
I love all warriors books and I know for a fact that this one will be just as good..........I totally ship finpaw and twigpaw (can't wait to read it)
TBH I am a little overwhelmed at the excessive amounts of Warriors books, but this one wasn't half bad.
I thought (spoiler) Finleap was a little annoying in this one and (spoiler) Twigbranch could have had a better warrior name (sorry) and (spoiler) Tigerheart=Tigerstar was kinda weird but hey it's fine anyway.
I am so glad it ties in with Tigerheart's Shadow. It is a really good book, but I wished that it had continued a bit more what it was like after (spoiler) Tigerheart became Tigerstar (in name, not personality)
Ok, this book is awesome, but it's leaving me very confused at the same time (Sorry Twigbranch, but your new warriors name is terrible. Erin Hunter why)
In Tigerheart's Shadow, Rippletail is one of the missing cats. Next thing you know he's a kittypet, and Slatefur is apparently with him instead (source: Warriors Wiki). *mind blows up from confusion*
YES I'm so excited its already on order, though I think I might just buy it I already own shattered sky and darkest night